Restaurants

Catalina Island's dining scene is as diverse and vibrant as its natural beauty, offering a culinary journey that matches every palate. From casual seaside eateries offering fresh-caught seafood to upscale dining experiences with panoramic ocean views, there's a feast for every taste. Many restaurants source locally grown ingredients, ensuring freshness and quality in every dish. Whether you're after a laid-back lunch by the beach or a sophisticated evening meal, the island's restaurants promise a delightful gastronomic adventure.

Steve's Steakhouse

As you walk through the doors, the aroma of sizzling steaks, fresh seafood, and a hint of Mediterranean spices waft through the air, setting the tone for an unforgettable dining experience. The courteous and friendly service is immediately evident, making you feel welcomed and valued. Their signature steaks are cooked to perfection, with a beautiful char on the outside and a tender, juicy interior. The seafood is fresh from the ocean, with options that change depending on the season and availability. From the succulent shrimp to the flavorful fish, each dish is prepared with care and expertise.

The Lobster Trap

A favorite among both locals and visitors, this eatery specializes in local lobster, prepared to perfection and served piping hot with a side of their signature shrimp stuffing. The Lobster Trap's ambiance is as inviting as its food, offering a lively nightlife scene that perfectly complements its mouthwatering menu. Whether you're a seafood aficionado or simply looking for a memorable dining experience, The Lobster Trap promises a gastronomic adventure that will leave you craving more.

Buffalo Nickel

An iconic establishment, the Buffalo Nickel has been serving an exquisite fusion of Mexican and American cuisine since the 1980s. When you enter the restaurant, you'll be greeted by the aromas of sizzling meats and seafood, complemented by the rich flavors of traditional refried beans and colorful rice. From succulent steaks to specialty seafood dishes, every meal is a flavor experience that will leave you satisfied. Try their signature Buffalo Milk cocktail, a delightful concoction of top-shelf alcohol, velvety banana liqueur, and creamy decadence that will leave you wanting another sip. If you find yourself on Catalina Island, a visit to the Buffalo Nickel is an absolute must.

The Sandtrap

Located at the edge of the Catalina Island Golf Course, this is a great spot to grab breakfast, lunch or dinner! See Pedro at their patio bar for great margaritas, Buffalo Milks and other festive island cocktails! They're known for their happy hour and $2 tacos from 3 to 6 pm.